Surety Bonds Help Consumers Deal with Dishonest Auto Dealers

Obtaining a surety bond can help you if you're dealing with a dishonest auto dealer

A common misconception about motor vehicle dealer surety bonds is that they are for the protection of the dealership. Surety bonds are actually for the protection of the consumer and are essentially a guarantee that the dealership will follow honest and appropriate practices. This contract is then enforced by the surety company that issued the bond.

If dealerships use dishonest practices when selling their cars, then consumers can file a claim with the surety company. If the surety company determines that the claims are true, then it will pay reparations to the consumers for their losses. The dealership will then be responsible for reimbursing the surety company for the reparations paid to consumers.

Missouri Driver without Title for Seven Months

In a May 18 report, WATE 6 reporter Don Dare published a story about a family from Maryville, Missouri who was unable to drive their newly bought car for seven months. Dare said Storm Taylor bought a Volkswagen for his daughter in November from Kingston Pike Motors used car dealership in Maryville. Taylor’s daughter Bronte Taylor, 16, needed temporary tags to drive her car while the dealer registered the car and transferred the title to the Taylor family’s loan company.

Temporary tags last for 30 days, and under Missouri state law, two sets of temporary tags are allowed to be issued by the dealer. After a month with no title, Storm Taylor went back to the dealer and was issued a second set of temporary tags. When the second set expired in January, he returned to the dealership again, only to find that it was now vacant.

Dare said Taylor tried calling owner David Pinkerton, but Pinkerton never replied. In this situation, Taylor should have filed a claim with the surety company to receive reparations for his financial losses. Luckily for Taylor, car salesman Darrell Stinnett was able to acquire the title from a former associate of Pinkerton’s. Dare also said that similar activity was reported by other consumers who bought cars from Pinkerton.

Ohio Attorney General Announces Lawsuit Against Used Car Dealer

In another May 18 report, the Norwalk Reflector published a similar story about a used car dealership in Chesapeake, Ohio. Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine announced a lawsuit against Ohio Valley Auto Sales owner Don A. Rice III. Rice is accused with violating Ohio’s Certificate of Motor Vehicle Title Act by failing to issue titles to consumers.

According to the Norwalk Reflector report, DeWine’s office received about 22 complaints from consumers that did not obtain titles after purchasing vehicles from Rice’s used car dealership. As Attorney General, DeWine approves all surety bonds filed in Ohio, so he was also able to assist in obtaining titles for some consumers and reimbursing others who could not obtain one.

Consumers were reimbursed through the Title Defect Rescission Fund, which is a program set up to help consumers who do not receive a title after purchasing a vehicle. According to the report, DeWine is seeking “a declaration that the defendants’ actions violated state consumer laws, an injunction to stop further violations, reimbursement to the Title Defect Rescission Fund, and civil penalties” in the lawsuit.

This is why it is so important for auto dealers to have surety bonds. Consumers can be protected from dishonest dealer practices, and honest dealers can get credit for their acceptable practices. In some cases, the surety company can revoke the bond and the dishonest dealer can no longer operate their business. If the dishonest dealers can be pushed out of the industry, then the consumers will have less clutter to sift through to reach the honest dealers. prides itself on successfully working one-on-one with clients in order to guarantee the issuance of the bonds they need both quickly and easily. If you are a current or prospective auto dealer and need to adjust your existing bond or get a new one, please contact one of our agents today. We are available 7am-7pm CST Monday through Friday to answer any questions or take your application over the phone. Call 1 (800) 308-4358 or fill out a bond request form online now.

Sign Up for Surety News!

About the Author

Jon Gottschalk
Jon Gottschalk is the Senior Marketing Director for and regularly blogs at the Surety Bond Insider to keep consumers informed on new legislation and updates in the commercial surety industry. He is also a licensed property & casualty insurance producer in Missouri.